[Community-Discuss] Share About Cloud Innovation Ltd and their business

[Arnaud AMELINA]

Le mar. 3 août 2021 à 23:09, Ronald F. Guilmette <rfg at tristatelogic.com> a
écrit :


> In message <

> CAGDMR_cL96mMUfNsdq8k2PSsdRSYw1Jiz_K2NShiSYBe7S5ksQ at mail.gmail.com>

> Arnaud AMELINA <amelnaud at gmail.com> wrote:

>

> >As I said before, history knows who were in the place when all resources

> >were provided to CI. After some research, we can summarize as follows:

> >

> >Adiel was not the ceo who allocated all the numbers and we can see how the

> >allocations went 1st /12  2nd /12 and then the 1st /11 and 2nd /11 and all

> >this happened within a 12 months time frame!

>

> I'm sorry, but your information is just not accurate.  The version history

> of each block provides the correct information about the original

> allocation dates, and it is as follows:

>

>     2013-07-24 -- 154.80.0.0/12

>     2014-12-01 -- 45.192.0.0/12

>     2015-12-22 -- 156.224.0.0/11

>     2016-09-23 -- 154.192.0.0/11

>

> Do you disagree with this timeline?  If so, on what basis?

>


No you're right on this one, thanks for the correction, apologize fort the
mistake.



> Th names of board members or board chairmen on these dates is perfectly

> irrelevant because the board never reviewed any of these allocations,

> or any of the documents or other materials that were used to justify them.

> The allocations were all made as a result of "staff" decisions, not the

> board.

>


You can't be totally sure on this one, because it was the period we saw the
Board playing the CEO Prerogatives, and entering in the micromanagement of
AFRINIC, remember.



> The first two of these allocations were granted under CEO Akplogan, who

> did not leave his CEO position until January 31, 2015:

>

>     https://afrinic.net/20140917-ceo-adiel-akplogan-resign




I'm OK with this one too, but he already resigned before the allocation,
isn't it?



>

> The two later allocations were granted under CEO Barrett.

>


If do so, how come New CEO gave 2 of /11 in such a short time?


>

> ALL of the allocations were made during a time period when Ernest

> Byaruhanga

> was a high-ranking officer of AFRINIC.

>



You're right on this one too.



>

>

> In my opinion, -all- of these allocations are suspect, and they are made

> moreso because neither Lu Heng nor his apparent primary spokesman here,

> Owen DeLong, has seen fit to share with any of us any of the materials or

> documentation that was used to provide the required justifications for

> any of these allocations -originally- even though it is 100% clear that

> all such records, dating back nearly five years ago to over eight years

> ago, are no longer in any sense relevant to Cloud Innovation's -current-

> business model or business operations.

>

> The time for dark secrets is over.  Lu Heng has elected to try his case

> on the mailing lists and in the press.  OK.  Fine.  Then let's do that.

>

> The question of whether or not Lu Heng's -current- usage of his IP space

> does or does not meet acceptable criteria is irrelevant if his -original-

> justifications for the space were in any way inadequate or less than

> truthful.  So let's see those original justifications and let the people

> decide whether or not Lu Heng even deserved to be granted this much IPv4

> space in the first place.

>

> Only Lu Heng can give us those original justification documents, if he so

> chooses.  AFRINIC is still bound by confidentiality rules and thus cannot

> legally provide them to any party outside of AFRINIC.

>

>

> Regards,

> rfg

>

> _______________________________________________

> Community-Discuss mailing list

> Community-Discuss at afrinic.net

> https://lists.afrinic.net/mailman/listinfo/community-discuss

>

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://lists.afrinic.net/pipermail/community-discuss/attachments/20210803/c1e04968/attachment.html>