Search RPD Archives
[rpd] co-chairs are also community members
Frank Habicht
geier at geier.ne.tz
Fri Nov 20 05:09:49 UTC 2026
Dear all,
I would like to state that I also support the position that co-chairs
can be authors of policy proposals.
Regards,
Frank Habicht
On 11/19/2026 3:04 AM, Seun Ojedeji wrote:
> Hello Jordi,
>
> I did not fully participate at the session today due to conflicts.
> However I see a lot of merit in your mail. Some of the candidate
> requirements are definitely strange and can be subjective.
>
> 1. The text says "majority," which seems like a typo; I am assuming
> "maturity" was intended? If yes then I don't see why maturity is a
> requirement. I have no problem with putting an age requirement to
> reflect that an adult is expected to chair PDWG. That can be 18 years or
> older.
>
> 2. It is absurd and strange that a PDWG member who is an author cannot
> run for Co-chair; in fact, such a person should be more welcome as it
> means he/she/they are active and very much engaged. The only exception
> that I think can be added is to flag that should a situation arise where
> both elected Co-Chairs happen to be authors of the same policy the RPD
> would appoint a chair for that policy alone from the floor while they
> both recuse themselves.
>
> Now that is a very unlikely situation; hence, PDWG will always have a
> co-chair who is not conflicted. When I was co-chair, I authored a draft
> policy and as per conflict of interest I simply recused myself and my co
> chair chaired the session. Co-chairs are adults; we should allow some
> level of trust and of good faith
>
> 3. I have no problem requiring 2 resource members. I am not sure what
> "distinct" means, and regardless, there's no reason to require
> it. Requiring only a resource member is sufficient. That could be
> qualified with "member in good standing."
>
> I hope we will not be too restrictive, thereby unintentionally
> disqualifying good candidates.
>
> Regards
> ----
> Sent from my mobile
> kindly excuse typos
>
>
>
>
>
> On Wed, 18 Nov 2026, 3:56 pm jordi.palet--- via RPD, <rpd at afrinic.net
> <mailto:rpd at afrinic.net>> wrote:
>
> Hi all,
>
> This afternoon we had this discussion, with for me it is a shame.
>
> How come anyone in the world can understand from the existing PDP (3.3):
>
> “The Policy Development Working Group has two Chairs to perform its
> administrative functions.”
>
> This other sentence:
> “The Policy Development Working Group has two Chairs to perform
> *EXCLUSIVELY* its administrative functions.”
>
> So the interpretation being done by AFRINIC (organization, Board,
> legal counsel, etc.), means that when community members are elected
> as co-chairs, they LOSE their rights as community members.
>
> So they can’t provide “hat-off” (personal, not as co-chair),
> opinions. This is contrary to what is being done in the other RIRs
> or the IETF. Chairs, staff, board members, are also community
> members, and volunteering (or being paid for) a specific position,
> doesn’t take away their LEGAL rights to still participate as a
> regular individual.
>
> The only need is to ensure demonstrating their neutrality, to
> clearly state, as done in other RIRs, IETF, etc., “hat-off … my
> personal view or experience on this is xxx”.
>
> This doesn’t mean they will act subjectively when judging consensus!
>
> Otherwise, it is like saying to someone "you’re not allowed to come
> into this shop because you’re a thief”, even if never he/she
> committed a robbery before in that shop.
>
> And here there is no need to amend the PDP for that: it is just a
> matter of not *reading* words that don’t exist in the PDP like
> *EXCLUSIVELY*. May be I’m somehow blind and these words are in the
> PDP in a color that I can’t see?
>
> Furthermore, we need to consider that the *real* participants in the
> RPD and PPM discussions is always a reduced group of the same
> people. If we don’t allow some of them, because they volunteered for
> co-chair, board, nomcom, appeal or other committees to also
> contribute, we are reducing the chances for wider discussions and
> inputs.
>
> And this is also related to the co-chair election process, which is
> discriminatory for the same reason (and many others), which in many
> jurisdictions will be a clear discrimination act and can be brought
> to courts.
>
> When a previous co-chair, being co-author of a policy proposal,
> volunteered to serve as a co-chair, it was reminded by the staff to
> withdraw as co-author. I openly complained against that, same
> argument, being a co-chair doesn’t mean you lose the “status” of
> community member. Never got a response on that.
>
> This time, *in exactly the same situation* another co-author who
> volunteered for co-chair, has been discriminated (vs the previous
> case) by not reminding him to withdraw as co-author. How come we can
> accept that?
>
> The real problem is how the board reached the conclusion that they
> can discriminate people for being elegible for a community position.
> Looking into the rule for being a co-chair (https://
> elections.afrinic.net/election-guidelines-2026 <https://
> elections.afrinic.net/election-guidelines-2026>) I can see several
> discriminatory points:
>
> 1) have attained the age of majority??????? 1st, I don’t know if it
> is the same age in all the countries in the region, but then, where
> in the PDP say anything about age of majority? So if a person with
> 16-17 years is today perfectly capable of using the Internet and
> participating in the discussions, why he/she will not be able to be
> a co-chair? It is not about age, it is about being able to
> understand the process. Of course, I don’t expect this to happen,
> but if it happens?
>
> 2) “or that of any other RIR” ? I don’t think this is being used in
> any other RIR. I think the point is just to have been active in this
> region.
>
> 3) “as well as of current draft proposals” ? no sense at all. Those
> proposals may reach consensus before the candidate term starts. What
> is needed is an understanding of the process and any proposal, if a
> proposal is not clear, then the proposal has a problem, not the
> candidate.
>
> 4) “not be the author …” totally ridiculous. One of the reasons we
> have multiple co-chairs is to resolve this situation, when one of
> the chairs needs to abstain for whatever reason with a specific
> proposal. A co-chair, in all the regions and in the IETF, can be an
> author. A co-chair may decide to write a proposal while he is a co-
> chair, and there is nothing that prevents that. A co-chair may be
> the only author of a proposal and needs to withdraw it before
> volunteering, even if this proposal my reach consensus BEFORE he is
> elected? A co-chair, may participate as an individual (stating hats-
> off) in any discussion. This is honest. Anything else is just not
> transparent and against the full PDP. By the way, the rules say
> “author” not “co-author”, so one more contradictory point that once
> more shows how a candidate has been discriminated.
>
> Further, a bad faith co-chair candidate, may be behind a policy
> proposal using a colleague to drive it thru the process and
> missmanage the process to get consensus on that proposal. This is
> much worst than a co-chair clearly abstaining (and thus being honest
> and transparent) from declaring consensus in a proposal that he is
> authoring or co-authoring.
>
> This decision consequently MUST BE APPEALED. I’m happy to start that
> and even consider courts, if the candidate that was discriminated in
> this election doesn’t want to appeal himself.
>
> In addition to that, the RPD community needs to clearly have a
> discussion on all this (that’s why this email) and take a firm
> position and the board follow it, because the board is not on top of
> the community on PDP matters, and the co-chairs and their functions
> are part of the PDP, not AFRINIC as an organization.
>
> Similar point as for the code of conduct, if it must be followed by
> RPD members, it needs to be discussed with the community. I recall
> it was done some time ago, why not this time? Send a draft, we
> discuss it, and we provide suggestions, etc.
>
> Otherwise (and this is just an example) the community should send
> policy a proposal and have our own code of conduct. Ah … of course,
> I forgot the point, then maybe the board will not ratify it, even if
> this is not play against the organization.
>
> Once more, as I said during the day, several times, by-laws of
> AFRINIC of course, need to have specific considerations because is
> based in Mauritius so it is different that all the other RIRs, but
> this doesn’t mean the by-laws need to encroach the community and the
> bottom-up process.
>
> Hopefully we can have a good discussion on these points.
>
> Note that I’m not, in this email, discussing any specific policy
> proposal (I will work in other email threads in the next days for
> that), just open discussion that clearly shows that the co-chairs
> don’t have “exclusivity” and the election process is a community
> process, with our own rules, not a board decided rules that are
> clearly discriminatory. I’m fine if the board prefer to have the
> nomcom to be used to facilitate the process, but doing the rules a)
> Not contradicting the PDP (the exclusivity thing), b) Being arranged
> in an open discussion with the community, at least until the
> community has (if necessary) a policy proposal more specific for
> elections.
>
> And with all that said I will shut up for today. Safe trip back home
> to those traveling!
>
> Regards,
> Jordi
>
> @jordipalet
>
>
> **********************************************
> IPv4 is over
> Are you ready for the new Internet ?
> http://www.theipv6company.com <http://www.theipv6company.com>
> The IPv6 Company
>
> This electronic message contains information which may be privileged
> or confidential. The information is intended to be for the exclusive
> use of the individual(s) named above and further non-explicilty
> authorized disclosure, copying, distribution or use of the contents
> of this information, even if partially, including attached files, is
> strictly prohibited and will be considered a criminal offense. If
> you are not the intended recipient be aware that any disclosure,
> copying, distribution or use of the contents of this information,
> even if partially, including attached files, is strictly prohibited,
> will be considered a criminal offense, so you must reply to the
> original sender to inform about this communication and delete it.
>
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> RPD mailing list
> RPD at afrinic.net <mailto:RPD at afrinic.net>
> https://lists.afrinic.net/mailman/listinfo/rpd <https://
> lists.afrinic.net/mailman/listinfo/rpd>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> RPD mailing list
> RPD at afrinic.net
> https://lists.afrinic.net/mailman/listinfo/rpd
More information about the RPD
mailing list