Search RPD Archives
[rpd] Co-chairs are also community members
Paul Hjul
hjul.paul at gmail.com
Thu Nov 19 07:20:04 UTC 2026
Two disclaimers: 1) I was in another event when the co-chair issue was on
the agenda and only have the snippet my brother sent me (actual brother 😄)
2) I don't know off hand who the nom com at present is nor who implemented
the "conditions" I am also unsure which text is referring to "age of
majority" but it's certainly not the CPM.
I am very supportive of a proper presence of AfriNIC at AfricaCom (although
the later branding is being dropped but that's another discussion) and a
short policy meeting during the event is an incredibly powerful way to get
the actual entities that are the resource members to be able to engage and
be engaged. Unfortunately I think two problems emerged as an implementation
aspect - it was quite a lengthy agenda compared to the meeting at AIS and
the Hyatt is outside of the "adjacent" benefit on a day when there is
really really a ton of things going on.
I cannot see on any fair reading of the CPM any requirement that a co-chair
not be a co-author of a proposal at the time they are nominated. For good
reason you don't want somebody who is author chairing a session but the
"co" is important here. Two co-chairs means one can step back on a policy
in which they have an interest and co-authoring can be a form of providing
assistance on a policy proposal rather than being the driver. More
importantly co-chairs are elected for the period after the meeting, so it's
perfectly sound to have somebody who had been involved in authoring to each
of the policies they authored either getting adopted or sent to the grave
to take up a co-chair role for the new proposals. Of course if an author
has proposals which don't achieve consensus and they are then a co-chair a
potential to fudge about arises BUT such a nominee should be rejected by
the meeting not gatekept out and in a candid good faith environment would
probably withdraw their nomination so that they can continue with the work
they were doing.
I haven't seen anything to suggest that either of the issues giving rise to
what might be felt to be a rather fruitless meeting can be pinned on the
board - and they know I won't hesitate to criticize if I see something -
but is rather a consequence of the general environment that is the AFRINIC
space.
The age of majority in SA was 21 and has been for more than 18 years 18. I
don't offhand think that there is any applicable African jurisdiction where
it is higher such as to cause a concern. As for the age of maturity that is
probably in this sector the period between 58-60 🤔 and by 70 we are back
to full YOLO. While requiring a person to be an adult with full legal
capacity etc ... should definitely apply to board membership I see no
reason why a co-chair felt to be suitable by the working group who is 16
should not be able to take up the role - as unlikely etc ... as it is. It
strikes me that whoever (and I fear its from the nomcom) introduced these
strictures is working on the premise the the working group is something
other than what it is.
I don't think it will be necessary - and it is a much more tricky road than
members of the working group or community would like think- for the issue
of who can be co-chair to be litigated. This is both because at worst the
working group has the co-chair as cleared by the nom com.
Paul
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://lists.afrinic.net/pipermail/rpd/attachments/20261119/5e21fa6d/attachment.html>
More information about the RPD
mailing list