Search RPD Archives
Limit search to: Subject & Body Subject Author
Sort by:

[rpd] New Draft Policy Proposal - Update of PDP AFPUB-2026-GEN-005-DRAFT01

sm+afrinic at elandsys.com sm+afrinic at elandsys.com
Thu Nov 19 23:41:05 UTC 2026


Dear Benson, Jordi,
At 10:59 AM 18-11-2026, Benson Muite wrote:
>I did not present today because AfriNIC asks people presenting to upload
>identity documents to their servers.  I have no idea who runs these
>servers, and who else has access to data stored on these servers.  The
>IETF does not ask for any identity documents to take part in their
>meetings online, though of course if one needed to travel and required a
>visa, one might need to provide a passport to get a visa support letter.

I wrote the policy development process for the region.  There wasn't 
any requirement in it for an author of a policy proposal to submit 
identity document at that time.  I attended the IETF meeting this 
week.  I was not required not to submit identity documents.

There was a case many years ago of an author not presenting his/her 
proposal.  The absence of the author were not because of a lack of 
open forum in which anyone may participate.  A (Mauritius) 
Cybersecurity and Cybercrime Act was introduced since that time.  I 
read it as a person on the street.  Section 16 is about the misuse of 
a fake profile.  Could that be the reason for requiring identity documents?

At 12:54 AM 19-11-2026, jordi.palet--- via RPD wrote:
>The IETF doesn't confirm your personal data against an ID, but it 
>must be *real and accurate* otherwise, you can be blocked from 
>participation, if I recall correctly. Not sure if is still there, 
>but there was a clear disclaimer for that for the registration.

I asked about that last year [1].  It was about the terms and 
conditions set for being able to attend an IETF meeting.  The terms 
and conditions were changed for the requirement to be publicly visible.

>Fortunately in IETF we didn't had the problems that showed up in 
>AFRINIC such as bunch of sudden registrations, people that nobody 
>knows, strange utilization of AI, etc.

I generated some statistics on the usage of AI: 
https://www.elandsys.com/r/88015  I haven't noticed a relatively 
similar increase in proposals here.  I could be mistaken as I read 
the list once in a while.  I don't see how requiring identity 
documents would solve an "AI" problem.  I still won't know either of 
you even if you showed me your identity documents.  Is there a 
technical standard which recommends that approach to solve an "AI" problem?

Regards,
S. Moonesamy

1. https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/ietf/mlJh71f9_KA4kTakeX95v55tacQ 




More information about the RPD mailing list