Search RPD Archives
Limit search to: Subject & Body Subject Author
Sort by:

[rpd] New Draft Policy Proposal - Update of PDP AFPUB-2026-GEN-005-DRAFT01

Mphoentle Mokheseng ST10120874 at vcconnect.edu.za
Fri Nov 20 07:09:50 UTC 2026


Dear PDWG,

I oppose this proposal as drafted. Parts of it are worth having; the package gives away too much to keep them.

The good parts: defining rough consensus rather than assuming it, and naming the mailing list explicitly as part of consensus. Both help anyone who cannot travel.

Three clauses need to come out.

First, 3.3 allows AFRINIC to "formally verify the identity of the persons forming part of the PDWG". A registry that decides who counts as a participant holds a permission gate over the community itself. Participation in a discussion list should be self-declared; coordinating unique identifiers does not require vetting who may speak.

Second, the consensus text lets the Chairs disregard expressions of support for an objection once they consider it technically refuted, without recording which objection was answered or where. Combined with the provision that consensus may be determined without a PPM presentation at the Chairs' discretion, that is unreviewable power over the outcome.

Third, a version expires after six months unless the Chairs submit it to the Board, while the same text requires eight weeks of list discussion, a four-week impact analysis and a PPM presentation. With two PPMs a year, a version that misses one cycle can expire for reasons its author does not control — which makes expiry a decision the Chairs hold, not a deadline.

What would make it acceptable: keep the consensus definition and the list's role; drop the identity verification; require the determination to record each substantive objection and why it was treated as resolved; remove the discretion to skip the PPM presentation; and pause the expiry clock while an impact analysis or a PPM slot is pending.

Regards,
Mphoentle
Disclaimer This email and the information contained herein are Advtech Ltd confidential and are protected by law. Please navigate to our website for more information https://www.groupadvtech.com. Use of this information or this email by any person for any purposes other than that for which it is intended is prohibited and may result in civil and/or criminal liability. This email is not to be shared with any 3rd parties not included within this email, without the written consent of its Author. If you have received this message in error, please notify Advtech immediately, telephone number +27 11 676 8000. Advtech leads the private sector in the fields of education and resourcing, contributing meaningfully towards the sustainable development of human capacity in South Africa.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://lists.afrinic.net/pipermail/rpd/attachments/20261120/10f9d709/attachment-0001.html>


More information about the RPD mailing list