Search RPD Archives
[rpd] New Draft Policy Proposal - Update of PDP AFPUB-2026-GEN-005-DRAFT01
jordi.palet at theipv6company.com
jordi.palet at theipv6company.com
Thu Nov 19 08:54:41 UTC 2026
Hi Benson,
See below, in-line.
Regards,
Jordi
@jordipalet
> El 18 nov 2026, a las 19:59, Benson Muite <benson_muite at emailplus.org> escribió:
>
> "jordi.palet--- via RPD" <rpd at afrinic.net> writes:
>
> Hi Jordi,
>
> Thanks for your reply.
>
>> Hi Benson,
>>
>> Sorry the late response, too busy with IETF matters and regular day job to keep up with the list this week and the previous one.
>>
>> Some responses below, in-line.
>>
>> Regards,
>> Jordi
>>
>> @jordipalet
>>
>>> El 13 nov 2026, a las 19:11, Benson Muite <benson_muite at emailplus.org> escribió:
>>>
>>> Hytham El-Nakhal <hytham at tra.gov.eg> writes:
>>>
>>>> Dear PDWG,
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> We have received a new draft policy proposal named "Update of PDP" with ID: AFPUB-2026-GEN-005-DRAFT01.
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> The proposal contents are published at:
>>>> https://www.afrinic.net/afpub-2026-gen-005-draft01
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> This proposal is an update to the expired proposal with ID: AFPUB-2021-GEN-002-DRAFT03 https://www.afrinic.net/update-of-pdp-draft-3x . The version history of the current proposal will allow you to consult the past versions for reference purposes.
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> We encourage you to take some time to go through the proposal contents and provide feedback as follows:
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> * a) Do you support or oppose the proposal?
>>>
>>> The proposal will improve how the policy development process, but may
>>> need adjustments.
>>>
>>>>
>>>> * b) If you oppose the proposal, state your reasons.
>>>
>
> One part that I am opposed to is the vague identity verification. At
> present, should there be a data leak on the part of AfriNIC, only people
> in Mauritius would have easy recourse to legal action, or in case of
> appeal to higher courts, people in the United Kingdom. Thus collecting
> ID information is problematic. Furthermore, some people who use the
> internet may not have government issued identity documents, or even
> worse, may have multiple government issued identity documents.
I’m fully for privacy, in fact I’ve presented almost 2.000 cases to the Spanish Data Protection on that, just in a couple of years (mainly for capturing illegally my emails and sending spam).
I was required to send my passport online in the registration process even if I was participating remotely. It looked strange to me, but I saw the privacy link in the bottom of the page, and it was fine and in line with what I can expect. Actually I recall Mauritius data protection regulation is similar to the EU GDPR.
I will be personally even more strict with data protection cases such as spam. Spammers hijack time from people. They should be punished with jail in persistent cases, same as a regular hijacker. Right now they only have fines, which are very difficult to get thru the Data Protection Agencies and even if they are fined, you need to go to courts for a compensation for the wasted time or for trying to use the spam for criminal activities (not sure in other countries, but in Spain almost impossible to get).
Back to the topic …. However the reason I included that in the proposal was because we have seen in AFRINIC several strange situations with the registration for the RPD, or the on-site participation.
May be we need to reconsider back that any participant in the PDP should be properly identified. In fact as said, if you need to provide your data because country regulations (I’m guessing), like in this meeting, why not doing it always?
>
> I did not present today because AfriNIC asks people presenting to upload
> identity documents to their servers. I have no idea who runs these
> servers, and who else has access to data stored on these servers. The
> IETF does not ask for any identity documents to take part in their
> meetings online, though of course if one needed to travel and required a
> visa, one might need to provide a passport to get a visa support letter.
I understand your point. Really pity that you or the staff didn’t explain that in the meeting (or before), so we could had some discussion on that.
Can the staff confirm the rationale for that (I may be wrong and was not a country regulation).
The IETF doesn’t confirm your personal data against an ID, but it must be *real and accurate* otherwise, you can be blocked from participation, if I recall correctly. Not sure if is still there, but there was a clear disclaimer for that for the registration.
I recall having required to provide an ID also in other RIR meetings for some activities (may be it was voting or something like that, not sure right now).
That said, even if I understand your point, I don’t agree, because as said, I trust Data Protection Agencies, and I personally have nothing to hide. Of course, it will be different if there is no Data Protection regulation that allows the one holding my data to sell it for other purposes, etc.
>
> It seems that even though one person one vote is not followed in the
> PDP, there is the hope of one person one voice. At present, given that
> there are 2000 resource members and typical PPM attendance is less than
> 100, clear and effective communication rather than identity verification
> would likely be more important. Public key cryptography does allow one
> to tie an email address to an identity. Resource members make payments,
> so requiring a public key from a reource member when making a payment is
> one way of verifying identity. Other participants could make a small
> token payment e.g. $1 or be required to send an SMS as a way of
> verifying that there is a person - this could still be gamed, just like
> identity documents - but the aim should be to have authentic productive
> discussion without preventing interested parties from participating and
> without unnecessary data harvesting.
>
Yes, clearly the election process (and let’s be clear, nothing about the presumable elected candidate), was not *clean* because the rules and the process was discriminatory … I’ve already started another thread on that yesterday night.
However, even if I’m for “enforcing” the members to participate in the PDP, this is a problem that we have in all the RIRs, and there is no way to achieve that, no way to enforce members to truly participate. We could, for example, offer a discount in membership, but then their participation will be only to “comply” with the rules, not necessarily a real consideration of the proposals, etc.
If I were a resource member, I will understand that the PDP is the way I’ve to do what my business requires and influence on that, but even if technical people in resource members understand that, not necessarily their boss do in the same way to allow them to invest time.
There is also the point that, like in IETF, in the RIRs the participation is not necessarily linked to the company you work for. In fact it may happen that you company has a view, and you personally have a different one - I think in that case is fine to state both, but your boss may not like it, so you may need to register in the RPD with a company email and personal email - and I think that’s fine … In IETF is even more strict: we are just individuals (even in the mic before using the Meetecho queue - much better than Zoom, we needed to state the company - but you’re not actually enforced to set a company in your registration, etc.).
Fortunately in IETF we didn’t had the problems that showed up in AFRINIC such as bunch of sudden registrations, people that nobody knows, strange utilization of AI, etc.
>
>>>
>>>>
>>>> * c) Is there anything in the proposal that is not clear?
>>>
>>> The definition of consensus could be improved. Many policies have both
>>> technical and social considerations. If a policy proposal is not
>>> technologically feasible, then it cannot be implemented. There may
>>> however be proposals that are possible technically, but would do much
>>> soical harm. It is not clear that the current definition of consensus
>>> could accomodate such a situation.
>>>
>>
>> The definition of rought consensus in the RIRs comes from IETF RFC7282. However, the PDP doesn’t explain it. The reason why the definition of consensus is included in the proposal, is so there is a short summary. We aren’t changing the way consensus is determined by the chairs, just making a short summary so everyone is aware of that.
>>
>> I agree with your point: However, in the end all the decisions have a technical part (for example, we can’t allocate more IPv4 addresses if none are left in the pools, so we need to have a soft landing when time comes, so there is no social harm).
>
>
>
>>
>>>>
>>>> * d) What changes could be made to this proposal to make it more effective?
>>>
>>> The suggestions for time periods for people to discuss a proposal are
>>> helpful. A 5 minute discussion to determine if consensus has been
>>> reached either forces proposals to go through two PPMs or requires very
>>> fast decision making that maybe liable to errors.
>>
>> Yes, this is a key point. 3 out of 5 RIRs are already doing that without asking the chairs to rush in decisions in 5 minutes (which also steals precious time from the agenda). Only AFRINIC and APNIC still do that. LACNIC was doing that until a proposal like this one changed it, and it has been successful for 7-8 years already. In IETF and other sister organizations is also not done in a rush.
>>
>>>
>>> Section 3.4.5 could be updated to account for the fact that an online
>>> PPM can be held to get community feedback. In most cases, scheduling an
>>> online PPM within a month is reasonable. There can be situations that
>>> prevent an online PPM, afpub-2026-gen-001 tries to address some of
>>> these.
>>>
>>
>> I’m not sure we want a PPM for just community feedback, for that we have the webinars, and of course, they can be scheduled in a shorter period of time, as it has been always the case.
>>
>
> If the board is making an important decision that affects the community,
> then a presentation at least at one PPM seems to be norm for community
> feedback that might not be picked up on the mailing list. This could be
> revised, but waiting potentially upto 6 months to rectify an emergency
> decision when one can use the internet seems inefficient.
>
**********************************************
IPv4 is over
Are you ready for the new Internet ?
http://www.theipv6company.com
The IPv6 Company
This electronic message contains information which may be privileged or confidential. The information is intended to be for the exclusive use of the individual(s) named above and further non-explicilty authorized disclosure, copying, distribution or use of the contents of this information, even if partially, including attached files, is strictly prohibited and will be considered a criminal offense. If you are not the intended recipient be aware that any disclosure, copying, distribution or use of the contents of this information, even if partially, including attached files, is strictly prohibited, will be considered a criminal offense, so you must reply to the original sender to inform about this communication and delete it.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://lists.afrinic.net/pipermail/rpd/attachments/20261119/97c610fb/attachment-0001.html>
More information about the RPD
mailing list