[rpd] Last Call - RPKI ROAs for Unallocated and Unassigned AFRINIC Address Space AFPUB-2019-GEN-006-DRAFT03.

[Nishal Goburdhan]

On 24 Jul 2021, at 14:48, Ben Maddison via RPD wrote:


> If you are asking about the process for issuing AS0 ROAs for reclaimed

> resources (or previously allocated resources in general), I believe 

> the

> only safe answer is "once consent has been given by the previous 

> holder".


that’s *a* safe answer, but certainly not the *only* answer.  and 
rather than point to many cases where this is not the the only safe 
answer, i’ll point instead to a suggestion that was made earlier : 
draw up a solid operating practice for when/how this can/should be 
applied.  part of that operating policy would likely include something 
like:  “if the claim to the address space is being contested in a 
court of law, then no changes should be made to IRR/ROAs..”  (that of 
course, needs to be cleaned up, to be made mode appropriate!)

and so, in a case like we are seeing unfold, a “no change” to the 
state of CI’s ROAs / IRR objects should be the process that’s 
followed, until there’s an answer from the court.  frankly, i’m 
unsure why anyone would think different about this?  if the court’s 
eventual ruling is in favour of afrinic, then, regardless of whether, or 
not CI gives their “consent”, afrinic can act to reclaim the space 
(and follow the relevant associated behaviour).  if the court rules in 
favour of CI, well,..this discussion is moot ..

there’s precedent for this;  when we authored the lame delegation 
policy we wrote an operating guide for what we thought would amount to a 
safe implementation for afrinic to follow.  ben/owen/noah, you’re 
savvy enough to see the value of AS0 ROAs, and to suggest text for edge 
cases (like this).  why not offer to help afrinic author that part of 
the operating manual, so that we end up with the best of both worlds?  
(frankly, i’d see that as a good opportunity to review and comment on 
their regular reclamation process too, but .. i can’t speak for what 
afrinic might be willing to entertain)

-n.