[rpd] End of Last call

[Noah]

On Thu, Oct 8, 2020 at 10:59 PM ABDULKARIM OLOYEDE <
oloyede.aa at unilorin.edu.ng> wrote:


> Dear Jordi and PDWG,

> *We made sure we followed the CPM to the letter on this issue,*

>


You did not.



> and we believe that we did our best to bring this issue that has been a

> pain to the community laid to rest in a timely manner.

>


What do you mean as a pain to the community. This is about your believes
and this is where you folk don't seem to understand. You can't sneak a
proposal past last call just because you think or believe you are laying
something to rest in a timely manner.



> As said earlier, whichever way we go, some would object to it,

>


Valid, invalid and sustained objections are what policy development is all
about. This is not about your subjectivity or belief that at the end of the
day some will object.

Of Course the working group will object as long as issues are not addressed
and that is how the PDP works.



> and we decided to deal with this once and for all

>


It's not your place as co-chairs to decide to deal with things once and for
all. Consensus is a matter of both the entire PDWG if you somehow forgot.



> in the best interest of the community with the least possible pain to the

> community.

>


What is in the best interest of the community when you ignore and
subjectively force a proposal forward in light of all objections and calls
by a good number of working group members to take this flawed proposal back
for discussions. You ignore the email from staff about reciprocity which
you yourself jumped to ask Madvhi for help on the issue.



> You elected us to serve the best interest of the community while leaving

> behind emotional issues, and we would continue to do just as best as we

> can.

>


Save me the rhetoric about "the best interest of the community" because you
are doing very poorly if you asked me.

Noah
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://lists.afrinic.net/pipermail/rpd/attachments/20201008/003b8843/attachment-0001.html>