[rpd] AFRINIC PDWG Co-Chair Selection - Outcome

Wed Jun 1 18:23:01 UTC 2022

Dear Policy Liaison,

I am not in anyway surprised by your email. Like I said in the room earlier
today I see a clear collaboration between you and some others.
I have no doubt in my mind about this.

1. The criteria to be nominated by a resource member was never agreed too
and you went on to implement it. Just as you have made false claims about
having elections. Please tell me where this was agreed too.

2. You said the Nic HDL does not match did you contact the email and the
person denied the nomination?

3. You also make a false claim that the seconder does not provide an email
address. If the email was not provided how do you expect the seconder to
comment on the matrix.  Why didn't you publish the provided information in
the matrix you published earlier.

It so funny that you can detect and correct a typo in a policy proposal
earlier today that changes the entire meaning of the sentence but you cant
detect or correct a simple error in NIC HDL. Very funny.

I know this email would not change anything cos you have made up your mind
on how to go about things and no matter the argument on here.
You are determined on what to do and like the so called  consensus today
when the author himself admitted that there is a controversial clause and
you and the other guys decided consensus has been reached. I know the
decisions were  premeditated.

I have had enough of this and I would do anything as long as I live to make
sure that the right thing is done.

AK

AK

On Wed, 1 Jun 2022, 13:08 AFRINIC Policy Liaison, <
policy-liaison at afrinic.net> wrote:

> *Dear PDWG*
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> * We would like to thank all those participants  who have contributed to
> the selection of the PDWG Chair exercise.  The steps carried out until now
> are as follows :- 1. The eligibility criteria were published on the website
> and announced to the RPD Mailing List on 10 May 2022 2. The call for
> nomination was opened for 6 days inclusive of the extension period. It
> closed on 15 May 2022 3. Four nominations were received. 4. Policy Liaison
> Team assessed the nominations received and updated the matrix , which was
> subsequently shared with the PDWG on 19 May 2022 . 5. The PDWG discussed
> the matrix and the candidates most apt to serve as PDWG Chairs. We would
> also like to clarify certain elements based on the mailing list posts :- In
> the case of Prof Nasir Faruk , the nominator nic-hdl provided in the
> nomination form did not match that of the registered contact of the said
> organisation.  The seconder did not provide an email address. We also noted
> that neither the nominator , nor the seconder commented on the matrix
> either  to shed more light or correct any discrepancy. We would also like
> to remind this PDWG that upon submission of a nomination form, both the
> nominator and seconder email addresses receive a copy of the form. This
> allows them to verify the information that was provided. From the mailing
> lists posts, the  preference of the Working Group leans towards Darwin Da
> Costa.  Kind Regards Policy Liaison Team ………………….. Cher PDWG, Nous tenons à
> remercier tous les participants qui ont contribué à l'exercice de sélection
> du co-président du PDWG.  Les étapes suivies jusqu'à présent sont les
> suivantes :-. 1. Les critères d'éligibilité ont été publiés sur le site web
> et annoncés à la liste de diffusion de la liste RPD le 10 mai 2022. 2.
> L'appel à candidature a été ouvert pendant 6 jours, y compris la période de
> prolongation. Il a été clôturé le 15 mai 2022 1. Quatre candidatures ont
> été reçues. 2. L'équipe de liaison politique a évalué les candidatures
> reçues et a mis à jour la matrice, qui a ensuite été partagée avec le PDWG
> le 19 mai 2022. 3. Le PDWG a discuté de la matrice et des candidats les
> plus aptes à assurer le poste  de co-présidence du PDWG. Nous souhaitons
> également clarifier certains éléments sur la base des messages de la liste
> de diffusion. Dans le cas du Prof Nasir Faruk, le nic-hdl du nominateur
> fourni dans le formulaire de candidature ne correspond pas à celui du
> contact enregistré de ladite organisation.  Le second n'a pas fourni
> d'adresse électronique. Nous avons également noté que ni le nominateur, ni
> le second n'ont commenté la matrice pour apporter plus de lumière ou
> corriger toute anomalie. Nous souhaitons également rappeler au PDWG que
> toute soumission de formulaire de candidatures, les nominateurs et les
> seconds reçoivent par email une copie dudit formulaire. Cela leur permet de
> vérifier les informations qui ont été fournies. Selon les discussions de la
> liste de diffusion, la préférence du groupe de travail va à Darwin Da
> Costa. Cordialement Équipe de liaison politique ……………………… عزيزي PDWG نود أن
> نشكر جميع المشاركين الذين ساهموا في اختيار تمرين رئيس PDWG. الخطوات التي تم
> تنفيذها حتى الآن هي كالتالي: - تم نشر معايير الأهلية على الموقع الإلكتروني
> وتم الإعلان عنها في القائمة البريدية لـ RPD في 10 مايو 2022 فتح باب الترشيح
> لمدة 6 أيام شاملة فترة التمديد. تم إغلاقه في 15 مايو 2022 ووردت أربعة
> ترشيحات. قام فريق تنسيق السياسات بتقييم الترشيحات المستلمة وتحديث المصفوفة
> ، والتي تمت مشاركتها لاحقًا مع PDWG في 19 مايو 2022. ناقش PDWG المصفوفة
> والمرشحين الأكثر ملاءمة للعمل كرؤساء PDWG. نود أيضًا توضيح بعض العناصر
> بناءً على منشورات القائمة البريدية: - في حالة الأستاذ ناصر فاروق ، فإن
> المرشح nic-hdl المقدم في نموذج الترشيح لا يتطابق مع جهة الاتصال المسجلة
> للمنظمة المذكورة. لم يقدم الثاني عنوان بريد إلكتروني. لاحظنا أيضًا أنه لم
> يعلق أي من المرشح أو الثاني على المصفوفة إما لإلقاء مزيد من الضوء أو تصحيح
> أي تناقض. نود أيضًا أن نذكر PDWG هذا أنه عند تقديم نموذج الترشيح ، يتلقى كل
> من عناوين البريد الإلكتروني المرشح والموظف نسخة من النموذج. هذا يسمح لهم
> بالتحقق من المعلومات التي تم توفيرها. وفقا للنقاش في قائمة البث للبريد
> الالكتروني تميل نوايا فريق العمل نحو Darwin Da Costa أطيب التحيات فريق
> اتصال السياسة ………………………. Caro PDWG Gostaríamos de agradecer a todos os
> participantes que contribuíram para a selecção do exercício da cadeira do
> PDWG.  As etapas realizadas até ao momento são as seguintes :- Os critérios
> de elegibilidade foram publicados no website e anunciados na Lista de
> Discussão do RPD a 10 de Maio de 2022 O convite à apresentação de
> candidaturas foi aberto por 6 dias, incluindo o período de prorrogação.
> Encerrou a 15 de Maio de 2022. Foram recebidas quatro nomeações. A Equipa
> de Ligação Política avaliou as nomeações recebidas e actualizou a matriz,
> que foi subsequentemente partilhada com o PDWG a 19 de Maio de 2022 . O
> PDWG discutiu a matriz e os candidatos mais aptos a servir como Presidentes
> do PDWG. Gostaríamos também de esclarecer alguns elementos com base nas
> postagens da lista de correio :- No caso do Prof. Nasir Faruk , o nic-hdl
> do nomeador fornecido no formulário de nomeação não correspondia ao do
> contacto registado da referida organização.  O segundo não forneceu um
> endereço de correio electrónico. Também notámos que nem o nominador , nem o
> segundo comentou a matriz para esclarecer ou corrigir qualquer
> discrepância. Gostaríamos também de lembrar a este PDWG que, ao submeter um
> formulário de nomeação, tanto o nominador como o segundo endereço de
> correio electrónico recebem uma cópia do formulário. Isto permite-lhes
> verificar a informação que foi fornecida. A partir das mensagens das listas
> de correio, a preferência do Grupo de Trabalho inclina-se para Darwin da
> Costa. Cumprimentos Equipa de Ligação de Políticas *
>
> --
> AFRINIC Policy Liaison.
> t: +230 403 51 00 | f: +230 466 6758 | tt: @afrinic | w:www.afrinic.netfacebook.com/afrinic | flickr.com/afrinic | youtube.com/afrinicmedia
>
> _______________________________________________
> RPD mailing list
> RPD at afrinic.net
> https://lists.afrinic.net/mailman/listinfo/rpd
>
>

-- 
Website <http://www.unilorin.edu.ng>, Weekly Bulletin 
<http://www.unilorin.edu.ng/index.php/bulletin> UGPortal 
<http://uilugportal.unilorin.edu.ng/> PGPortal 
<https://uilpgportal.unilorin.edu.ng/> HelpDesk 
<http://www.unilorin.edu.ng/index.php/more-resources/e-notices/6845-how-to-resolve-email-portal-login-problems-for-staff-and-students>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://lists.afrinic.net/pipermail/rpd/attachments/20220601/3871118b/attachment-0001.html>