[rpd] Proposal Update received: AFRINIC Number Resources Transfer Policy

[Sylvain Baya]

{Cc: Ernest}

Hi all,

...please see below (inline).

Le lundi 21 octobre 2019, Fernando Frediani <fhfrediani at gmail.com> a écrit :


> Hello Sylvain.

>

> I consider that the main motivation to allow transfers for IPv4 is the

> scarcity. In normal

>

> conditions, including a M&A the company would have to receive resources in

> the new

>

> RIR and do renumbering.

>


Dear Fernando,
I understand your arguments, but we must not force an entity, resulting
from a Merger|Acquisition,
to act the way you described. It seems to me like going a bit out of the
scope of the PD-WG. The
Merger|Acquisition entity should be free to use at least the Internet
resources they have legally
inherited. Or am i missing something ?

...or it's not really the goal: treat the Merger|Acquisition case into this
single Draft Policy
Proposal (DPP) ?

Any author to clarify ? :-/

An other thing : after reading the Staff comment as IAr (Impact Analysis
report) for this DPP and
considering an explanation given by Ernest, i understand that there is
problem to solve within
the Merger|Acquisition particular case before considering them as potential
beneficiary of this
DPP.



>  Some people say that renumbering has costs, but that is part of the

> business and should

>

> be accounted as part of the whole transaction.

>


...IMHO, the Merger|Acquisition entity should be free to use your good
advice Fernando ;-)



> Allowing IPv6 transfers has the potential to mess up with the way it was

> distributed and is

>

> allocated among all RIRs

>


...including RIPE NCC, yes and in that particular RIR, IPv6 transfers are
allowed ; including for
Inter-RIR Transfers. And not only for the good of Merger|Acquisition
entities (In|Out of region).



> (remember there are no Legacy IPv6) and also would have costs

>

> for RIRs to adapt they systems in order to allow that, a cost that would

> be of all members

>


Thanks for this interesting information, hopefully we could have a new IAr
or a at least a Staff
response about this affirmation.

...so, Ernest, can you consider contacting RIPE NCC Staff to provide us
with a kick response ?
Thanks for your understanding.



> in order to accomplish the need of just a few.

>


Fernando, if we want a business stability into this region, preferably we
should understand
Merger|Acquisition advantages more than something which could only harm the
greatest part of
resource members of this RIR. To be clearer, i see Merger|Acquisition
scenarios inside AFRINIC
region. That is why, i'm insisting for the authors to include IPv6 in their
$resource pool|definition.

Also, the *few* you have mentioned below are not known right now :'-(
...then, any AFRINIC given resource member could become part of a
Merger|Acquisition scenario
at any time...

...let me go further, in my analysis i also see, in fact, a potential legal
risk in regard to the RSA
which seems to clearly grant Merger|Acquisitions entities with a kind of
*business continuity right*
or guarantee. If i have read it correctly, though :-/

Thanks.

Shalom,
--sb.


> Regards

> Fernando

> On 21/10/2019 14:24, Sylvain Baya wrote:

>

> Hi all,

>

> Le lundi 21 octobre 2019, Fernando Frediani <fhfrediani at gmail.com> a

> écrit :

>

>> [...]

>>

>


-- 


-- 

   Best Regards !

  Sylvain BAYA
 cmNOG's Co-Founder & Coordinator
   (+237) 677005341
 PO Box 13107 YAOUNDE / CAMEROON
baya.sylvain [AT cmNOG DOT cm]
 abscoco2001 [AT yahoo DOT fr]
 http://www.cmnog.cm
 https://cmnog.wordpress.com
 ************************
  ‪#‎LASAINTEBIBLE‬(‪#‎Romains15‬:33):"Que LE ‪#‎DIEU‬ de ‪#‎Paix‬ soit
avec vous tous!‪#‎Amen‬!"
‪#‎MaPrière‬ est que tu naisses de nouveau.
‪#‎Chrétiennement‬
             « Comme une biche soupire après des courants d’eau, Ainsi mon
âme soupire après toi, ô DIEU! » (Psaumes 42 :2)
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://lists.afrinic.net/pipermail/rpd/attachments/20191022/0ba6ac42/attachment.html>