Search RPD Archives
[rpd] co-chairs are also community members
jordi.palet at theipv6company.com
jordi.palet at theipv6company.com
Wed Nov 18 20:53:53 UTC 2026
Hi all,
This afternoon we had this discussion, with for me it is a shame.
How come anyone in the world can understand from the existing PDP (3.3):
“The Policy Development Working Group has two Chairs to perform its administrative functions.”
This other sentence:
“The Policy Development Working Group has two Chairs to perform *EXCLUSIVELY* its administrative functions.”
So the interpretation being done by AFRINIC (organization, Board, legal counsel, etc.), means that when community members are elected as co-chairs, they LOSE their rights as community members.
So they can’t provide “hat-off” (personal, not as co-chair), opinions. This is contrary to what is being done in the other RIRs or the IETF. Chairs, staff, board members, are also community members, and volunteering (or being paid for) a specific position, doesn’t take away their LEGAL rights to still participate as a regular individual.
The only need is to ensure demonstrating their neutrality, to clearly state, as done in other RIRs, IETF, etc., “hat-off … my personal view or experience on this is xxx”.
This doesn’t mean they will act subjectively when judging consensus!
Otherwise, it is like saying to someone "you’re not allowed to come into this shop because you’re a thief”, even if never he/she committed a robbery before in that shop.
And here there is no need to amend the PDP for that: it is just a matter of not *reading* words that don’t exist in the PDP like *EXCLUSIVELY*. May be I’m somehow blind and these words are in the PDP in a color that I can’t see?
Furthermore, we need to consider that the *real* participants in the RPD and PPM discussions is always a reduced group of the same people. If we don’t allow some of them, because they volunteered for co-chair, board, nomcom, appeal or other committees to also contribute, we are reducing the chances for wider discussions and inputs.
And this is also related to the co-chair election process, which is discriminatory for the same reason (and many others), which in many jurisdictions will be a clear discrimination act and can be brought to courts.
When a previous co-chair, being co-author of a policy proposal, volunteered to serve as a co-chair, it was reminded by the staff to withdraw as co-author. I openly complained against that, same argument, being a co-chair doesn’t mean you lose the “status” of community member. Never got a response on that.
This time, *in exactly the same situation* another co-author who volunteered for co-chair, has been discriminated (vs the previous case) by not reminding him to withdraw as co-author. How come we can accept that?
The real problem is how the board reached the conclusion that they can discriminate people for being elegible for a community position. Looking into the rule for being a co-chair (https://elections.afrinic.net/election-guidelines-2026) I can see several discriminatory points:
1) have attained the age of majority??????? 1st, I don’t know if it is the same age in all the countries in the region, but then, where in the PDP say anything about age of majority? So if a person with 16-17 years is today perfectly capable of using the Internet and participating in the discussions, why he/she will not be able to be a co-chair? It is not about age, it is about being able to understand the process. Of course, I don’t expect this to happen, but if it happens?
2) “or that of any other RIR” ? I don’t think this is being used in any other RIR. I think the point is just to have been active in this region.
3) “as well as of current draft proposals” ? no sense at all. Those proposals may reach consensus before the candidate term starts. What is needed is an understanding of the process and any proposal, if a proposal is not clear, then the proposal has a problem, not the candidate.
4) “not be the author …” totally ridiculous. One of the reasons we have multiple co-chairs is to resolve this situation, when one of the chairs needs to abstain for whatever reason with a specific proposal. A co-chair, in all the regions and in the IETF, can be an author. A co-chair may decide to write a proposal while he is a co-chair, and there is nothing that prevents that. A co-chair may be the only author of a proposal and needs to withdraw it before volunteering, even if this proposal my reach consensus BEFORE he is elected? A co-chair, may participate as an individual (stating hats-off) in any discussion. This is honest. Anything else is just not transparent and against the full PDP. By the way, the rules say “author” not “co-author”, so one more contradictory point that once more shows how a candidate has been discriminated.
Further, a bad faith co-chair candidate, may be behind a policy proposal using a colleague to drive it thru the process and missmanage the process to get consensus on that proposal. This is much worst than a co-chair clearly abstaining (and thus being honest and transparent) from declaring consensus in a proposal that he is authoring or co-authoring.
This decision consequently MUST BE APPEALED. I’m happy to start that and even consider courts, if the candidate that was discriminated in this election doesn’t want to appeal himself.
In addition to that, the RPD community needs to clearly have a discussion on all this (that’s why this email) and take a firm position and the board follow it, because the board is not on top of the community on PDP matters, and the co-chairs and their functions are part of the PDP, not AFRINIC as an organization.
Similar point as for the code of conduct, if it must be followed by RPD members, it needs to be discussed with the community. I recall it was done some time ago, why not this time? Send a draft, we discuss it, and we provide suggestions, etc.
Otherwise (and this is just an example) the community should send policy a proposal and have our own code of conduct. Ah … of course, I forgot the point, then maybe the board will not ratify it, even if this is not play against the organization.
Once more, as I said during the day, several times, by-laws of AFRINIC of course, need to have specific considerations because is based in Mauritius so it is different that all the other RIRs, but this doesn’t mean the by-laws need to encroach the community and the bottom-up process.
Hopefully we can have a good discussion on these points.
Note that I’m not, in this email, discussing any specific policy proposal (I will work in other email threads in the next days for that), just open discussion that clearly shows that the co-chairs don’t have “exclusivity” and the election process is a community process, with our own rules, not a board decided rules that are clearly discriminatory. I’m fine if the board prefer to have the nomcom to be used to facilitate the process, but doing the rules a) Not contradicting the PDP (the exclusivity thing), b) Being arranged in an open discussion with the community, at least until the community has (if necessary) a policy proposal more specific for elections.
And with all that said I will shut up for today. Safe trip back home to those traveling!
Regards,
Jordi
@jordipalet
**********************************************
IPv4 is over
Are you ready for the new Internet ?
http://www.theipv6company.com
The IPv6 Company
This electronic message contains information which may be privileged or confidential. The information is intended to be for the exclusive use of the individual(s) named above and further non-explicilty authorized disclosure, copying, distribution or use of the contents of this information, even if partially, including attached files, is strictly prohibited and will be considered a criminal offense. If you are not the intended recipient be aware that any disclosure, copying, distribution or use of the contents of this information, even if partially, including attached files, is strictly prohibited, will be considered a criminal offense, so you must reply to the original sender to inform about this communication and delete it.
More information about the RPD
mailing list