[rpd] Publication of Information (Draft-2) - AFPUB-2021-GEN-001-DRAFT02

[Gaby Giner]

Hi Jordi, hi everybody,

Thanks for a quite insightful proposal. However, this type of proactive
action (and the details/parameters that you gave) may not translate well
into reality.

Transparency and fairness are important values ofc, given that we operate
behind the screen. My concern with the policy would be the parameters that
you gave. Do you have a solid statistical basis that says in 2 years, a
probable business that asked for resources from AFRINIC would be able to
establish their business properly without adverse effects if ever AFRINIC
should do as it says in the policy proposal?

Secondly, your last paragraph:
*"This policy shall be implemented in such a way that all the resources
allocated/assigned for over 2 years, will be chronologically warned,
allowing the staff to process the possible responses of “non-disclosure”
without requiring extra human resources."*
I'm having trouble understanding this in context with the other content in
the proposal. Maybe a rewrite is in order.

Finally, for the first paragraph, I would suggest that it should be
rewritten. On the whole, while transparency is good, I think the execution
should be considered carefully.

Sincerely, Gaby.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://lists.afrinic.net/pipermail/rpd/attachments/20211112/338a9406/attachment-0001.html>