[rpd] Call for interest for PDWG chairs closed & Way forward

[Daniel Yakmut]

These are after thought criteria, So it can't be applicable. By the way 
where is this stated in our books?


Cheers

Daniel

On 06/04/2021 11:42 am, Murungi Daniel wrote:

> Dear Yakmut,

>

> I agree with Jodi on item 4, any candidates who have co-authored 

> policies that are still under discussion or appeal should be 

> disqualified on the basis of conflicting interests. If the candidate 

> in question were a Co-Chair and had their policy passed, it would be 

> impossible for the community to determine whether the decision was 

> unbiased or self serving.

>

> Regarding item 1, the candidate who faked nominator information should 

> be immediately disqualified as they have proven their lack of 

> integrity and shown blatant disrespect for the community at large.

>

>

> Regards,

> Murungi Daniel

>

>

>> On 6 Apr 2021, at 1:06 PM, Daniel Yakmut via RPD <rpd at afrinic.net 

>> <mailto:rpd at afrinic.net>> wrote:

>>

>> Dear Jordi,

>>

>> I disagree with you on the candidate that has a policy in discussion 

>> to be disqualified. That is a n-no, rather the candidate should 

>> provide a statement of withdrawing is authorship of the policy and 

>> that should suffice.

>>

>> on item 3, the failing is coming from the Secretariat, and they are 

>> the ones drawing our attention to it. So I want to believe they have 

>> done well here.

>>

>> Aside the above, If others are proven to correct as per your 

>> comments, then I also agree that such candidates stand disqualified.

>>

>>

>> Simply

>>

>> Daniel

>>

>>

>> On 05/04/2021 9:16 pm, JORDI PALET MARTINEZ via RPD wrote:

>>

>>> Hi,

>>>

>>> I’ve several issues on this email and also looking into the data 

>>> provided by the candidates in their CVs.

>>>

>>>  1. If I understood correctly, one of the candidates used fake data

>>>     for his nominator. If that’s true, that is clearly a

>>>     disqualifying factor, not only because there is no a member

>>>     support, but also because we can’t trust on anyone providing

>>>     fake data.

>>>  2. Has the staff verified all the nominators so this is not

>>>     happening in other cases?

>>>  3. I fail to see how the form has worked fine for several days, and

>>>     then didn’t worked on the last date. Can you provide the logs of

>>>     the server and email server to verify that fact in a 100%

>>>     trustable way?

>>>  4. I see at least one candidate with a policy still in discussion,

>>>     under appeal, so that should disqualify that nomination.

>>>  5. I see a couple of candidates which doesn’t have any experience

>>>     in network operations or anything similar, so that would also

>>>     disqualify them?

>>>

>>> I don’t think we need to wait for the NomCom, because this can be 

>>> very easily done by the secretariat, at least some of the points are 

>>> totally neutral and transparent, such as the verification of the 

>>> nominators, the verification of the form failure, verification of 

>>> the data provided in the CVs, etc.

>>>

>>> This will allow to move on at least a couple of days in case the 

>>> NomCom need to take a decision of who is qualified to run or not.

>>>

>>> Regards,

>>>

>>> Jordi

>>>

>>> @jordipalet

>>>

>>> El 5/4/21 20:51, "AFRINIC Policy Liaison" 

>>> <policy-liaison at afrinic.net <mailto:policy-liaison at afrinic.net>> 

>>> escribió:

>>>

>>> [Français en bas]

>>>

>>> Dear PDWG,

>>>

>>> The Call of Interest for the PDWG Co-Chairs Selection pursuant to 

>>> Section 3.3 of CPM is now closed.

>>>

>>> *1.**_List of nominees_***

>>>

>>> AFRINIC is in receipt of  six (6) nominations which are as follows :-

>>>

>>> 1.Wijdane Goubi from Morocco, Country of Residence: Morocco

>>>

>>> 2. Anthony Ikechukwu Ubah from Nigeria, Country of Residence: Canada

>>>

>>> 3. Vincent Ngundi from Kenya, Country of Residence: Kenya

>>>

>>> 4. Abdulkarim Oloyede from Nigeria, Country of Residence: Nigeria

>>>

>>> 5. Darwin Da Costa from Angola, Country of Residence: Angola

>>>

>>> 6. Ibeanusi Elvis from Nigeria, Country of Residence: Japan

>>>

>>>

>>>

>>> 2.*_Additional elements_*

>>>

>>> a.Nominee - Ibeanusi Elvis

>>>

>>> This nomination which was received as a self-nomination appeared to 

>>> have been made later than the deadline. This was due to a back-end 

>>> issue on self-nomination forms that was addressed during the day 

>>> today. We confirm that the nomination has been posted on the system 

>>> within the deadline.

>>>

>>> b.Nominee - Widjane Goubi

>>>

>>> In regard to  the nominee,  Wijdane Goubi, kindly note that on the 

>>> 5th of April 2021, AFRINIC has been informed by an email sent from 

>>> the designated nominator on the nomination paper that the latter 

>>> never provided its support to the said nomination.  He has therefore 

>>> requested AFRINIC to delete all its associated personal data in 

>>> connection thereof. In this respect, and  to comply with the 

>>> Mauritian Data Protection Act 2017, AFRINIC has a duty to cause such 

>>> deletion forthwith and you are accordingly informed of the same. “

>>>

>>> *_3. Tenure of Office_*

>>>

>>> We would like to remind the Working Group that  as stated in Section 

>>> 3.3 of the Consolidated Policy Manual, one Co-Chair  will serve a 

>>> term ending by the PPM to be held in June 2021 only whereas the 

>>> other will serve a term ending in June 2022.

>>>

>>> *_ 4. Next Steps_*

>>>

>>> Now that the Call for Interests is closed, the next step is for the 

>>> Working Group to find consensus on the most suitable persons to 

>>> replace the recalled PDWG Co-Chairs.

>>>

>>> This exercise, including the carrying out of such due diligence and 

>>> shortlisting of candidates/nominees, would under normal 

>>> circumstances be carried out by the Nomination Committee (NomCom).

>>>

>>> For your information, the present NomCom has indicated that they 

>>> would be available to conduct such exercise only from April 8th 

>>> 2021. With only 6 candidates, we will leave the decision on the best 

>>> way of carrying out the due diligence and shortlisting process to 

>>> the PDWG participants.

>>>

>>> We therefore request you to agree on how the Working Group would 

>>> like to proceed with the selection of the 2 replacing PDWG’s Co-Chairs.

>>>

>>> Kind Regards

>>>

>>> Policy Liaison Team

>>>

>>> ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

>>>

>>> Cher PDWG,

>>>

>>> L'appel à manifestation d'intérêt pour la sélection des coprésidents 

>>> du PDWG conformément à la section 3.3 de la CPM est désormais terminé.

>>>

>>> *1.**Liste des nominés*

>>>

>>> AFRINIC a reçu six (6) candidatures qui sont les suivantes :

>>>

>>> 1.Wijdane Goubi du Maroc, Pays de résidence : Maroc

>>>

>>> 2. Anthony Ikechukwu Ubah du Nigeria, Pays de résidence : Canada

>>>

>>> 3. Vincent Ngundi du Kenya, Pays de résidence : Kenya

>>>

>>> 4. Abdulkarim Oloyede du Nigeria, Pays de résidence : Nigeria

>>>

>>> 5. Darwin Da Costa de l'Angola, Pays de résidence : Angola

>>>

>>> 6. Ibeanusi Elvis du Nigeria, Pays de résidence : Japon

>>>

>>> *2. Éléments supplémentaires*

>>>

>>> a.Candidat - Ibeanusi Elvis

>>>

>>> Cette nomination, qui a été reçue en tant qu'auto-nomination, 

>>> semblait avoir été faite au-delà de la date limite. Cela était dû à 

>>> un problème de back-end sur les formulaires d'auto-nomination qui a 

>>> été résolu aujourd'hui dans la journée. Nous confirmons que la 

>>> nomination a été postée dans le système dans les délais impartis.

>>>

>>> b.Candidat - Widjane Goubi

>>>

>>> En ce qui concerne la candidate, Wijdane Goubi, veuillez noter que 

>>> le 5 avril 2021, l'AFRINIC a été informée par un courriel envoyé par 

>>> son prétendu nominateur que ce dernier n'a jamais apporté son 

>>> soutien à ladite candidature. Il  a donc demandé à l'AFRINIC de 

>>> supprimer toutes les données personnelles associées à cette 

>>> candidature. À cet égard, et pour se conformer à la loi mauricienne 

>>> sur la protection des données de 2017, AFRINIC a le devoir de 

>>> procéder à ladite suppression sans délai et vous en êtes par 

>>> conséquent informé.

>>>

>>> *3. Durée du mandat*

>>>

>>> Nous souhaitons rappeler au groupe de travail que, comme indiqué à 

>>> la section 3.3 du CPM, l'un des co-présidents exercera son mandat 

>>> jusqu'à la PPM qui se tiendra en juin 2021 seulement, tandis que 

>>> l'autre exercera son mandat jusqu'en juin 2022.

>>>

>>> *4.  Prochaines étapes*

>>>

>>> Maintenant que l'appel à manifestation d'intérêt est terminé, la 

>>> prochaine étape consiste pour le groupe de travail à trouver un 

>>> consensus sur les personnes les plus aptes à remplacer les 

>>> coprésidents du PDWG destitués.

>>>

>>> Cet exercice, qui comprend la réalisation d'une évaluation diligente 

>>> et la sélection des candidats nominés, sera normalement effectué par 

>>> le comité de nomination (NomCom).

>>>

>>> Pour votre information, le NomCom actuel a indiqué qu'il ne serait 

>>> disponible pour mener cet exercice qu'à partir du 8 avril 2021. Avec 

>>> seulement 6 candidats, nous laisserons aux participants du PDWG le 

>>> soin de décider de la meilleure façon de mener à bien le processus 

>>> de sélection en faisant preuve de diligence raisonnable.

>>>

>>> Nous vous demandons donc de vous accorder sur la manière dont le 

>>> groupe de travail pourrait procéder à la sélection des deux 

>>> coprésidents remplaçants du PDWG.

>>>

>>> Nos Salutations

>>>

>>> Policy Liaison Team

>>>

>>>

>>>

>>> -- 

>>> AFRINIC Policy Liaison.

>>> t: +230 403 51 00 | f: +230 466 6758 | tt: @afrinic | w:www.afrinic.net  <http://www.afrinic.net>

>>> facebook.com/afrinic  <http://facebook.com/afrinic>  |flickr.com/afrinic  <http://flickr.com/afrinic>  |youtube.com/afrinicmedia  <http://youtube.com/afrinicmedia>

>>>

>>> _______________________________________________ RPD mailing list 

>>> RPD at afrinic.net https://lists.afrinic.net/mailman/listinfo/rpd

>>>

>>>

>>> **********************************************

>>> IPv4 is over

>>> Are you ready for the new Internet ?

>>> http://www.theipv6company.com

>>> The IPv6 Company

>>>

>>> This electronic message contains information which may be privileged 

>>> or confidential. The information is intended to be for the exclusive 

>>> use of the individual(s) named above and further non-explicilty 

>>> authorized disclosure, copying, distribution or use of the contents 

>>> of this information, even if partially, including attached files, is 

>>> strictly prohibited and will be considered a criminal offense. If 

>>> you are not the intended recipient be aware that any disclosure, 

>>> copying, distribution or use of the contents of this information, 

>>> even if partially, including attached files, is strictly prohibited, 

>>> will be considered a criminal offense, so you must reply to the 

>>> original sender to inform about this communication and delete it.

>>>

>>>

>>> _______________________________________________

>>> RPD mailing list

>>> RPD at afrinic.net

>>> https://lists.afrinic.net/mailman/listinfo/rpd

>> _______________________________________________

>> RPD mailing list

>> RPD at afrinic.net <mailto:RPD at afrinic.net>

>> https://lists.afrinic.net/mailman/listinfo/rpd

>

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://lists.afrinic.net/pipermail/rpd/attachments/20210406/dc244cf1/attachment-0001.html>